Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Daniel Sherrier's avatar

A talking Snoopy sounds weird. It works in the stage musical, but it was never necessary in the cartoon.

Expand full comment
Jayme Blaschke's avatar

Adults also were present and spoke in the absolutely terrible "This is America, Charlie Brown" TV miniseries that ran in 1988. On paper it must've been a good idea--get the Peanuts gang to do an infotainment journey from Plymouth Rock through the space age, but in reality it was just... bad. This was the era of a slew of Peanuts direct-to-video shorts and Schulz was clearly past his prime at this point.

One can get away with a talking Snoopy in a live stage production, but other than that, there are problems. I remember as a kid being disturbed by the live-action broadcast of "You're a Good Man" back in 1973: https://youtu.be/ko33ihjklKQ?si=-lhXrbVzTFI6uAon

Expand full comment
11 more comments...