Mills Means Monsters – The Secret “Origin” of Monster Cereals

Mills Means Monsters – The Secret “Origin” of Monster Cereals

It was a simple enough pitch as movie pitches go…Monsters. Who didn’t love monsters? They were powerful, mysterious. Men wanted to be them and women wanted to be with them! (or was that leading men?) Anyway people DID love monsters. And they had made it big in film already thanks mostly to Mr. Lon Chaney! The man of a thousand faces. His genius portrayal of some of histories most revered monsters (a murdering clown, The Phantom of the Opera, the Hunchback of Notre Dame!) had put Universal Studios on the map and it only made sense to continue riding that money train to glory! As many film historians know, the Chaney monster films in the 1920’s had brought success but had also used up every single monster in human lore. What they needed was fresh meat! New monsters to bring chills up the spines of Mr and Mrs America! At least that was the driving force behind Herman Mills and his new breed of american movie monster.

Mills came from a long line of whole grain farmers living in rural Iowa, just outside of Happy Pines. The farm was a successful one supplying much of the Midwest with more wheat oats and corn then they could possibly handle but he wanted more. He wanted to make an impact on the world and he wanted it to be through the art of horror!! Like many farmers Herman had grown up watching monster movies and fell in love with the spooky art form. He wanted to be a part of that world and set about meticulously designing monsters. Monsters like the world had never seen before! He created sketches, background stories, rough film outlines…everything! He envisioned a series of films; each one showcasing the eerie goodness of one of his monstrous creations… eventually there could be crossover films that featured two of his monsters or even more! He knew in his heart of hearts that they would be a hit and with a cast like this how could he go wrong?

(Historical Sketch by: The Amazing Tom Krohne)

Count Chocula- An undead creature of the night…ageless. With the charm of an aristocrat and an undying thirst

Frankenberry- An monstrous abomination. The unnatural marriage of flesh and machine. An unstoppable force of nature.

Boo Berry- Corpse? Ghost? Who can tell. He rose to exact revenge for a wrong long since lost to the dust of time. His rage fuels his bloody quest.
Yummy Mummy- A lifeless hollow shell that was once a man. Propelled by a very mystic curse. Driven to destroy anyone or anything in its path.

And of course…

Fruit Brute- Tormented soul of a man forever cursed to dwell in the body of a vicious beast. A slave to the moon and its own cruel twisted fate.

Mills gathered his entire collection of information scripts sketches, and concept work into a thrift store briefcase and headed down to sunny Hollywood, California to make his dream a reality! Unfortunately, it seemed the world was not ready for Mills and his Monsters… Every studio that the starry-eyed man visited turned down his concept but in the end one rejection hurt most of all. Herman’s beloved Universal Studios declined to even let him finish his pitch. They stated that Universal was out of the monster business for good and wanted to focus their time and money into something called “cartoons” (which, by the way would never end up catching on) They agreed to take some of his information in case they ever changed their mind but they made it clear that this was incredibly unlikely.

Devastated, Mills returned to the family farm reinvesting himself into developing new and spookier ways of planting wheat fields! In 1931 Herman Mills received the most shocking blow of all. Universal studios had released a movie entitled Dracula. And the leading character Count Dracula was virtually identical to his character Count Chocula!! He had received no notice from Universal…no royalty check… Surely this was some kind of mistake…or maybe just a misunderstanding. He contacted the studio and was told they had no record of his visit to the company or of his monster movie pitch. Mills continued to hold on to the hope that the whole ordeal could have been a coinsidence. After all, as the crotchety but lovable owner of the charming local country grocery store said “stranger things have happened”

So he went about his life but the betrayal only got worse. Universal released Frankenstein; a pale (and not even pink!) ripoff of his Frankenberry character. Then the (not yummy) Mummy and the Wolf Man! In addition they released several films introducing the concept of a “ghost;” a concept wholly created by Mills with Boo Berry. Heartbroken and jaded, Mr. Mills set about the task of trying to recover from his dreams shattering before him.

It was no use…Universal Studios had taken everything. They even created a film called the Invisible Man and mirrored his character The Invisiberry Man perfectly. While not nearly as scary or well fleshed out, these “universal monsters” had effectively ended any chance that he would ever see his own characters in the spotlight. In one last desperate attempt to make it big, he pitched some light concept stuff to a young studio called Rankin Bass and since they needed some Halloween material they agreed almost immediately. The resulting film “Mad Monster Party” was released to much critical acclaim but was a box office flop and ultimately never reached anything beyond cult status. The world was apparently not ready for a stop motion vampire or a claymation werewolf.

Herman went back to the farm this time for good. He began to love the whole grains and the nourishment they provided. He knew they could be part of a balanced breakfast if eaten with toast, skim-milk and a glass of milk…and a glass of orange juice ( I mean honestly, who drink two different drinks with breakfast in two different glasses. It’s ridiculous!) Yes, Herman believed that if these whole grains could somehow be molded into interesting shapes and then put in a box of some kind why…even kids might eat it! So he devised a plan to revolutionize the breakfast world, he would call his product cereal (after the serial comic strips that he loved so well) But this “cereal” needed more than just fun shapes and a super cool rectangular box. It would need colorfully decorated cartoon boxes. Delicious flavors and catchy names…maybe even some kind of collectible toy that could provide endless nostalgia fuel in the years to come! Only the right combination of these could turn innocent children into obnoxious whining brats that would beg and scream until the product was dropped into the shopping cart by a desperate mother!

What he needed was inspiration and he didn’t have to look very far…it was the same answer he had turned to time and time again…Monsters! He got to planning a different cereal with its own unique flavor, and displayed on the box in all their glory…his creations! Anyone could see that Herman Mills was a whole grain genius! He knew how to make the best cereal on earth…and the flavoring was a no-brainer! In fact, weirdly enough, he noticed that the names of his monsters almost sounded like flavors already! With the help of his brother General Edward Mills (marshmallow hobbyist) he added that special finishing touch of the sweet spooky themed delights. After all everyone knows that marshmallows are what kids crave!

The rest, as they say is history. Herman and General Mills went on to fame and fortune, becoming sugary breakfast titans and creating one of the most beloved seasonal horror based food products in the history of the world. The characters on those cereal boxes have resulted in spin-offs such as video games, and animated series and even Mills Monsters: The Broadway Musical casting its influence into the entertainment world farther even than Universal Studios…the company that nearly ended the dream for good. The origin of Monsters Cereal really is a classic example of the American Dream. Not like Sugar Bear….now that story is weird!


Dedicated fan of puppets, horror and classic animation. Fueled by nostalgia and driven to spread my own brand of "truth" to the fandom. Remember playing as a kid and trying to tell a coherent story with totally mismatched, unrelated toys? It's like that....of the mind!

This Post Has 8 Comments

  1. It is good to know that the American Dream has worked for some people. I guess the takeaway from all of this is that you should persevere no matter what.

    This website originally started to sell AMC auto parts in Canada and look at it now…

  2. Great article! As an aside, I know Tom Krohne pretty well, always loved his rendition of the cereal monsters! You should check out his blog for much more monstery goodness!

  3. Another fantastic expose, CW! I’d always wondered about the “similarities” of those two brands…sadly I do not recall the animated series! It’s the problem with getting older I reckon.

  4. No wonder I always got the urge to nibble on some chocolate while watching my 8mm reel of Lugosi’s Dracula doing some neck nibbling.

  5. I am glad you mentioned General Edward Mills, he is often overlooked outside of marshmallow hobbyist circles.

  6. No. The site is supposed to be about retro stuff, not new stuff that you’ve made up. I really liked this site until you started posting these fake stories. I go to retro sites to remember my childhood, not read made up stuff. Can’t you write a real article ? These are really getting old.

  7. @Atari: Yeah man! and strangely enough it sometimes happens the other way around too!
    @Retroist: After doing the research for my post I became fascinated by the marshmallow hobbyist community. It’s a pretty tight bunch and it can be really tough to become accepted but what an amazing world!
    @Mattster! Yes! I want you to know that you are in very good company! The Retroist himself constantly asks me to stop posting but between you and me, I can’t control myself. I really appreciate your readership though and that’s The Truth!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Close Menu
%d bloggers like this: