Who plays a better Abe Lincoln — Daniel Day-Lewis or ANGUS SCRIMM?

A review of Shout! Factory’s special edition Blu-Ray of Phantasm II.

PhantasmII

Angus Scrimm is one of the biggest delights in this beautifully produced Phantasm II Blu-Ray. He’s all over this disc — in the documentary, in the behind the scenes and in the commentary. The reason I’m so obsessed in telling you this is because it’s a gift for us that the man still walks the earth at 87 years old AND is as sharp as a knife. I’ve never met him, so this disc was a real eye opener into who he is as a person and I just think he is super awesome. I pray that when I get to that age, I have the enthusiasm and wit he has.

For this reason ALONE, it’s more than enough to rush out and get this Blu-Ray. However, as your persevering nerd reviewer, I watched all 50 gigs on this optical disc and have to report it is a fine release that any true horror fan needs to have in their collection.

Phantasm II, released in 1988, was another horror film I had the privilege of seeing when it came out in theaters. I was about 15, but as I explained in my They Live review, I had an older brother who was passionate about the genre and for a few years, we pretty much saw every R-rated horror movie there was. It was a great time that I cherish. Seeing this film again brought back a lot of good memories of going to the movies.

I won’t bore you with a review of the film. Just know that it’s an awesome movie because, well…Reggie Bannister with a DIY four barrel shotgun. Need I say more? Let’s just get into why you’ll want to own this Blu-Ray as soon as inhumanly possible.

Ready….boyyyyy?

THE TRANSFER
The packaging does not advertise a remastered film transfer, so I don’t know if there was a DVD version like this before the Blu-Ray. I’ve only owned the film on VHS, so this is the best I have ever seen it. It’s a GORGEOUS transfer of the film. The movie is already beautifully shot, but this retains the grittiness of the film, while giving it a nice polish for high def.

THE EXTRAS
Someone at Shout! Factory knows their shit when it comes to these films. They manage to put together material that us fans love. My guess, they love this film as much as we do.

First up is a fantastic documentary with interviews from Coscarelli, Scrimm, the super cool Reggie Bannister, Paula Irvine, Samantha Phillips and Kenneth Tigar – the actor who played the tormented Perigord priest, Father Meyers, who knows what The Tall Man is up to. Added to that mix is the film’s producer Roberto Quezada, director of photography, Daryn Okada, the production designer Philip Duffin, and make-up effects wizard Mark Shostrom. It’s a cavalcade of the talent behind this film.

The doc is full of insight about the production. (Brad Pitt read for the part of Mike? Reggie Banister had to essentially re-audition for his OWN role?) There is a lot of cool stuff about the Spheres and TONS about how they did the effects. Also, you get the feeling that everyone just had a blast making the movie, which only makes me love the film more.

There is a really snazzy extra with deleted scenes that were from Coscarelli’s own work print. They spliced them into the finished scenes to give you the context of what it would look like when it was the full version. I love seeing the scratchy work print edited next to the clean mastered film. It’s the true film geek in me.

It also has a bunch of behind the scenes stuff that was shot back in 1988 on groovy video. Much of it has a young Howard Berger and Greg Nicotero — who worked for Shostrom’s shop — making masks, pumping blood and general tom foolery. I’ve met Nicotero and the man looks only about five years old than he does in these videos. He must be drinking Lurker’s blood or something.

There is also a doc about Nicotero’s work on the film that was pretty interesting. It looked like it had been produced for something else a few years ago and they put it in the Blu-Ray. Stick around for the credits on that one, there is a great little spoof that the effects team on Phantasm II made about a classic scene from the original Phantasm.

On top of all that, there are a bunch of trailers — including one for Phantasm and Phantasm III — a still photos gallery AND a really crazy old timey B&W short film about Abraham Lincoln! The reason it’s on the disc is that it stars Angus Scrimm (then credited as Rory Guy) as honest Abe himself. Take THAT Daniel Plainview!

CONCLUSION
Look, no one wants to die, end up being embalmed with some sort of reanimation goo, then put into a black vat, shrunken down to half our size and shipped off to an alternate dimension to become slaves. Okay, that’s PRETTY obvious. So, in order to stop that from happening, you have to get this disc! It gives you all the answers of how to protect yourself from supernatural grave robbers. Above that, this release is a great example of how TO put together a collectors edition Blu-Ray and if I ever meet the producer of this disc, he can bet I will unleash my Golden Super Sphere…right into his heart.

It’s available March 26. Order here from Shout! Factory. If you get your order in early, there is a limited edition poster in it for you!

Patrick J. Doody

Patrick J. Doody is a horror nerd and Mexican Pepsi enthusiast living in Los Angeles. Along with his writing and producing partner Chris Valenziano, he has been involved in such terrorific projects as Silent Hill: Homecoming for Konami, Scream Awards for Spike TV and Ghostfacers: The Web Series for Warner Brothers. Their film Beneath, starring Jeff Fahey, won Best Picture at Screamfest and is currently available on Netflix.

Subscribe to the Retroist Newsletter

* indicates required

2 thoughts on “Who plays a better Abe Lincoln — Daniel Day-Lewis or ANGUS SCRIMM?

  1. Charlton Hero says:

    In my horror loving phase as a teenager I remember the Phantasm series quite well. The Old man and the crazy silver bladed orb was all very cool. I am very interested in seeing this Blu Ray. Great article too by the way..info packed!

  2. Atari Adventure Square says:

    I really gotta get this and the first one as soon as I get a Blu-Ray player (I was waiting for one to pop up in a cereal box but…alas!).
    Yeah, Angus Scrimm created an iconic figure of Darkness that still haunts my dreams.

    But Daniel, you didn’t mention the elephant-sized Orb-in-the-room…
    Namely, the absence of the kid protagonist actor from the first movie!
    Michael Baldwin’s absence from Phantasm 2 made me discard the whole thing as a movie production – at that time.

    Y’see, Phantasm (1) wasn’t a movie, it was a waking, surreal nightmare from which never fully awoke.
    That weird crossover of graveyard gloom-horror, naked females turned into something nasty, Jawas oozing putrid malevolence and creeping fear of loneliness was purely from my late-teen brain.
    It just congealed into some celluloid presence all could see and hear (and mostly scoff and dismiss, to my evermore utmost horror) in that darkened theater, where our poor, doomed protagonist met his fate at the hands of his own fears.

    Just like any teenager surrendering to the crushing realization that adulthood was about to knock his head back and drill itself into the rest of his life, as his rebellious lifeblood gushed out liberally as we jerked and spazzed out, helpless to resist.

    Um…yeah.
    That first movie meant a lot to me.
    So the second one – with most of its cast returning except my avatar, meant it had indeed been just a dream.
    Or…was this one?

    Eh, I’ve made peace with it.
    Love the cast, crew, director and those flying silver balls of death in every single one of the Phantasms.

    But the rest of the series just awakes the original shivers Phantasm gave me.
    And that’s a good thing.

    Long live The Tall Man.

Comments are closed.